Sunday, November 15, 2026

To the Women of the House of C&A

Dear wives, daughters, and keepers of the house,

The men knew how to generate absolute contribution.  

You knew how to turn it into a family that lasted.

For generations the fortune that built your homes, educated your children, and sustained your families was not generated by complex financial theory or academic percentages.  

It was built on a simple, uncompromising piece of household arithmetic: counting money in hard cash, not soft proportions.

While outsiders looked at a coat, a suit, or a pair of socks and asked, “What is the gross margin percentage?” your husbands, fathers, and uncles knew better.  

Around the table they reminded one another: “You cannot take percentages to the bank.”  

The grocery store, the tailor, and the salaries are paid in cash, not ratios.

That wisdom—forged from Hamburg to Amsterdam and rooted in the absolute contribution model (Deckungsbeitrag)—understood a fundamental truth modern commerce often forgets:

In selling socks, 4 − 3 = 2 − 1.

The Core Formula:

Net Profit = Total Contribution Margin (hard cash from all items) − Operating Expenses

Where the contribution of each item is simply:  

Selling Price − Buying Price (cash) = Contribution per unit

Then:  

Contribution per unit × Units sold = Total cash contribution of that Style (Stock Keeping Unit (SKU)). 

When space, capital or shelf room is scarce, you rank items by relative contribution:  

Relative Contribution = Absolute cash contribution of the item ÷ Amount of the scarce resource it uses.

Generating absolute cash contribution to cover overhead and pay the salaries matters infinitely more than chasing an imaginary percentage point.

A Simple Example (Socks on the Same Shelf)

Imagine two styles of socks occupying the same shelf space for the same period, and the same number sold of each:

Style A:  
Selling Price €4  
Buying Price €3  
→ contribution €1 (25% margin)  
Sold 100 pairs → €100 total cash contribution

Style B:  
Selling Price €2  
Buying Price €1  
→ contribution €1 (50% margin)  
Sold 100 pairs → €100 total cash contribution

Selling Socks  

In selling socks, 4 − 3 = 2 − 1.  
Both put exactly the same absolute cash into the till.  

The higher percentage does not pay more salaries or more rent.

Buying Stocks (Shares)  

In buying stocks (shares), however, a move from 1 to 2 is a larger relative return than from 3 to 4.  

That difference in decision support — absolute contribution when selling socks under space constraints versus relative returns when buying stocks — is largely unknown in academic retail textbooks.

When the Accountants Took Over

For decades this was the unwritten law of the family business.  

It was the intuition that enabled C&A to dominate European retail through the mid-20th century, mirroring the absolute cash models later used by retail legends like Ingvar Kamprad at IKEA, Joe Coulombe at Trader Joe’s and Mrs B.'s Nebraska Furniture Mart which was bought by Warren Buffett. 

By the 1990s the culture shifted.  

Modern consultants and academic economists entered the boardroom.  

Veteran managers who dismissed gross-margin percentages as secondary were quietly written off as old-fashioned.
  
Seasoned retail people were sent to be “re-educated” on the sacred importance of percentages.  
Buyers began to starve high-volume basics of shelf space while guarding high-percentage specialty items that sat gathering dust — the classic Kmart trap.

The Result of Forgetting

The moment absolute cash accounting was traded for academic percentage worship, the core engine stalled.  
The old guard — the ones who knew that selling socks is not buying stocks, and that absolute contribution profit is the only metric that pays the bills — were sidelined.

The merchandise math used changed for the worse, although cash is still cash, and salaries are still paid in euros, not percentages.  

The corporate memory of how the fortune was actually made was buried under decades of textbook dogma.

The men knew how to generate absolute contribution.  
You knew how to turn it into a family that lasted.  

May we remember both.

Our new 2026 academic paper / pre-print by Dr. Björn Kijl, Steven Venrooy and Ansgar John B. 

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7644027

No comments: